Thanksgiving This or That: 150 Fun Questions for Every Gathering

Thanksgiving is about more than a delicious meal. It is a chance to reconnect, share stories, and laugh with the people around you.

But when the conversation slows down, a simple game can bring everyone together again.

These Thanksgiving This or That questions cover holiday favorites, funny dilemmas, family traditions, and creative challenges for kids, teens, adults, and Friendsgiving guests.


Quick Answer: What Is Thanksgiving This or That?

Thanksgiving This or That is an easy party game in which players choose between two options. For example, would you pick pumpkin pie or apple pie? Everyone shares their preference, and players can explain their choices if they want to.

There are no right or wrong answers. You can play at Thanksgiving dinner, in a classroom, at an office party, or during Friendsgiving. All you need is a list of questions and a few willing participants.


How to Play Thanksgiving This or That

The game takes only a few minutes to set up. You can keep it casual or turn it into a friendly competition.

  1. Gather everyone around the table or in a comfortable group.
  2. Choose a question and read both options aloud.
  3. Give players a few seconds to decide.
  4. Ask everyone to raise a hand, hold up a card, or move toward their preferred option.
  5. Invite a few players to explain their choices.
  6. Continue until you finish your selected questions.

Try this example: Ask, “Homemade cranberry sauce or canned cranberry sauce?” Everyone votes. Then ask someone to explain why their choice belongs on the Thanksgiving table.

Three Ways to Make the Game More Interesting

  • Majority vote: Players earn a point when they correctly predict the most popular answer.
  • Pick a side: Assign one side of the room to each option and let everyone move to their choice.
  • Question bowl: Write questions on slips of paper, place them in a bowl, and let players draw one at a time.

Thanksgiving Food This or That Questions

Food debates are a natural fit for Thanksgiving. Some people cannot imagine dinner without stuffing, while others save most of their appetite for dessert. These questions can start a lively conversation before the meal even begins.

  1. Turkey or ham?
  2. Pumpkin pie or pecan pie?
  3. Mashed potatoes or stuffing?
  4. Gravy on everything or gravy on the side?
  5. Homemade cranberry sauce or canned cranberry sauce?
  6. Sweet potato casserole or roasted sweet potatoes?
  7. Cornbread stuffing or traditional bread stuffing?
  8. Green bean casserole or roasted Brussels sprouts?
  9. Apple pie or pumpkin pie?
  10. Whipped cream or vanilla ice cream?
  11. Turkey breast or turkey leg?
  12. Mac and cheese or mashed potatoes?
  13. Dinner rolls or cornbread?
  14. Sweet potatoes with marshmallows or pecans?
  15. Deviled eggs or a cheese platter?
  16. Homemade dinner or store-bought sides?
  17. Crispy turkey skin or juicy turkey meat?
  18. Extra stuffing or extra gravy?
  19. Pumpkin bread or apple crisp?
  20. Apple cider or hot chocolate?
  21. Appetizers before dinner or saving room for the main meal?
  22. One large plate or several small servings?
  23. Pie for breakfast or pie after dinner?
  24. Turkey sandwich leftovers or turkey soup?
  25. A second helping of dinner or an extra slice of pie?
See also  Fact or Opinion: Key Differences, Examples, Worksheets & Quiz

Funny Thanksgiving This or That Questions

Sometimes the funniest questions are the ones nobody expects. Use these silly choices to break the ice, entertain cousins, or get everyone laughing while they wait for dessert.

  1. Talk like a turkey or walk like a turkey?
  2. Wear a giant turkey costume or a pumpkin costume?
  3. Eat pie with chopsticks or mashed potatoes with a spoon?
  4. Have a talking turkey or a singing pumpkin?
  5. Forget to buy dessert or burn the dinner rolls?
  6. Wear a silly Thanksgiving hat or oversized turkey socks?
  7. Sing every sentence or rhyme every sentence?
  8. Have a food fight with marshmallows or a pillow fight with dinner rolls?
  9. Carve a turkey with a tiny spoon or serve soup with a fork?
  10. Laugh during a serious toast or sneeze during a family photo?
  11. Have a turkey follow you everywhere or a pumpkin that keeps rolling away?
  12. Wear oven mitts all day or wear shoes two sizes too big?
  13. Tell the same joke ten times or hear the same story ten times?
  14. Find gravy on your favorite shirt or pie crumbs in your bed?
  15. Lose the TV remote or lose the dessert plates?
  16. Wash every dish by hand or clean the entire kitchen floor?
  17. Have a turkey that tells bad jokes or a pie that sings opera?
  18. Accidentally sit on the dessert or spill the gravy boat?
  19. Eat only side dishes for a day or eat only desserts for a day?
  20. Have to gobble before speaking or dance before every meal?

Thanksgiving This or That Questions for Kids

Children can join the fun without knowing every Thanksgiving tradition. These simple choices focus on familiar foods, creative activities, games, and things they enjoy doing with family.

  1. Turkey or chicken?
  2. Pumpkin pie or chocolate cake?
  3. Apple juice or hot chocolate?
  4. Play outside or watch a movie?
  5. Draw a turkey or color a pumpkin?
  6. Make a paper turkey or decorate a paper plate?
  7. Play hide-and-seek or play tag?
  8. Jump in autumn leaves or collect colorful leaves?
  9. Wear a cozy sweater or funny pajamas?
  10. Bake cookies or decorate cupcakes?
  11. Read a story or play a board game?
  12. Watch the Thanksgiving parade or watch cartoons?
  13. Build a blanket fort or make a fall craft?
  14. Mashed potatoes or corn?
  15. Make a thank-you card or give someone a hug?
  16. Play with cousins or invite a friend?
  17. Eat cupcakes with sprinkles or chocolate chips?
  18. Have a family picnic or a big dinner table?
  19. Play charades or solve a puzzle?
  20. Help decorate the table or help serve dessert?

For younger children, read each option slowly and let them point to their answer. Pictures can help if a child does not recognize a particular food or activity.


Thanksgiving This or That Questions for Teens

Teenagers may prefer questions about entertainment, social plans, hobbies, and holiday traditions. These options work well at a family gathering, a school event, or a casual Friendsgiving celebration.

  1. Friendsgiving or family Thanksgiving?
  2. Group photos or candid photos?
  3. Board games or video games?
  4. Watch a comedy or watch a mystery?
  5. Create a playlist or let someone else choose the music?
  6. Help cook dinner or decorate the table?
  7. Dress up for dinner or wear comfortable clothes?
  8. Share holiday photos online or keep them private?
  9. Watch football or play video games?
  10. Go shopping early or sleep in?
  11. Host a small gathering or attend a big party?
  12. Try a new recipe or stick to a favorite?
  13. Take a long walk or relax on the sofa?
  14. Make dessert or prepare a savory dish?
  15. Play trivia or play charades?
  16. Plan a themed outfit or a themed dinner?
  17. Watch a holiday movie or listen to music?
  18. Give handmade gifts or write thoughtful cards?
  19. Have a packed schedule or enjoy an unplanned day?
  20. Spend the evening chatting or playing competitive games?
See also  Coarse or Course: How to Choose the Right Word Every Time

Thanksgiving This or That Questions for Adults

These questions explore the practical choices that come with preparing for a holiday. They also give adults a chance to compare family traditions and share a few hosting stories.

  1. Host Thanksgiving or be a guest?
  2. Cook everything yourself or organize a potluck?
  3. Prepare food the day before or cook on Thanksgiving Day?
  4. Follow family recipes or experiment with new dishes?
  5. Set a formal table or keep things casual?
  6. Eat an early dinner or a late dinner?
  7. Invite a large crowd or keep the gathering small?
  8. Travel for Thanksgiving or stay home?
  9. Plan every detail or go with the flow?
  10. Watch the parade or watch football?
  11. Take a walk after dinner or take a nap?
  12. Wash dishes immediately or clean up later?
  13. Shop in person or shop online?
  14. Make a detailed shopping list or shop spontaneously?
  15. Save leftovers for lunch or freeze them for later?
  16. Buy dessert from a bakery or bake it at home?
  17. Keep old traditions or start new ones?
  18. Spend the holiday in the city or countryside?
  19. Enjoy a quiet evening or a lively celebration?
  20. Finish preparations early or work until the last minute?

Thanksgiving This or That Questions for Friendsgiving

Friendsgiving brings friends together for food, conversation, and shared memories. These questions suit roommates, college friends, coworkers, and anyone planning a relaxed holiday gathering.

  1. Potluck dinner or catered dinner?
  2. Matching outfits or mismatched outfits?
  3. A themed playlist or a movie marathon?
  4. Homemade dessert or a dessert tasting?
  5. Board games or party games?
  6. Secret thank-you notes or a group gratitude circle?
  7. Cook together or order food together?
  8. Fancy decorations or simple decorations?
  9. A group selfie or a photo booth?
  10. Trivia competition or charades tournament?
  11. Bring an appetizer or bring dessert?
  12. Eat indoors or enjoy an outdoor meal when the weather allows?
  13. Create a shared playlist or let everyone choose a song?
  14. Exchange small gifts or share favorite memories?
  15. End the evening with a movie or one last game?

Thanksgiving This or That Questions for Work and Classrooms

A short game can help coworkers and classmates relax without requiring anyone to share personal information. Choose neutral questions that work for different personalities and backgrounds.

  1. Team lunch or classroom celebration?
  2. Bring snacks or bring drinks?
  3. Decorate a shared space or decorate your desk?
  4. Play trivia or solve a word puzzle?
  5. Work in teams or play individually?
  6. Make a gratitude wall or write thank-you notes?
  7. Play a short game or organize a longer competition?
  8. Give a funny answer or a thoughtful answer?
  9. Make a fall craft or solve a holiday puzzle?
  10. Vote as a group or discuss answers in pairs?
  11. Create a themed snack table or a decorated photo area?
  12. Share a favorite food or share a favorite tradition?
  13. Win a small prize or earn team points?
  14. Start the event with an icebreaker or finish with one?
  15. Celebrate in person or join a virtual gathering?

Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions

This bonus section offers more challenging choices. Unlike short This or That questions, these prompts describe situations that require a little more thought.

  1. Would you rather cook the entire Thanksgiving meal or wash every dish afterward?
  2. Would you rather eat your favorite Thanksgiving dish every day for a month or skip it for a year?
  3. Would you rather host 20 guests or travel six hours to visit family?
  4. Would you rather forget to buy dessert or discover that the oven stopped working?
  5. Would you rather have Thanksgiving dinner at breakfast time or after midnight?
  6. Would you rather give up your favorite side dish or your favorite dessert?
  7. Would you rather organize every family activity or handle all the cooking?
  8. Would you rather spend Thanksgiving without television or without your phone?
  9. Would you rather try a completely new holiday menu or eat the same meal every year?
  10. Would you rather share one thing you appreciate about everyone or write a personal thank-you note to each guest?
  11. Would you rather have unlimited pumpkin pie or unlimited mashed potatoes?
  12. Would you rather serve dinner to a room full of picky eaters or cook for guests who love trying everything?
  13. Would you rather have every guest arrive an hour early or an hour late?
  14. Would you rather forget the cranberry sauce or run out of dinner rolls?
  15. Would you rather celebrate Thanksgiving in a snowy cabin or at a sunny beach house?
See also  Prey vs. Pray: Complete Guide to Meaning, Spelling & Usage

How to Choose the Best Questions for Your Group

You do not need to use all 150 questions in one sitting. Pick the ones that suit your audience and the time available.

  • For family dinner: Choose food favorites, funny situations, and family traditions.
  • For children: Use simple choices about games, crafts, food, and animals.
  • For teenagers: Include entertainment, social plans, and friendly challenges.
  • For adults: Focus on hosting, cooking, travel, and holiday routines.
  • For Friendsgiving: Use questions about shared meals, music, games, and friendship.
  • For classrooms and workplaces: Choose neutral topics that everyone can answer comfortably.

Avoid forcing anyone to explain an answer. Some players enjoy sharing their reasoning, while others prefer to vote and move on.


FAQs

What are some good Thanksgiving This or That questions?

Good questions offer two appealing or amusing choices, such as pumpkin pie or pecan pie, hosting Thanksgiving or being a guest, and watching the parade or watching football. The best options suit the group playing.

How many questions should you use for Thanksgiving This or That?

Ten to fifteen questions work well for a quick activity. For a longer gathering, select 30–50 questions or use different categories throughout the event.

Can you play Thanksgiving This or That with kids?

Yes. Choose simple, age-appropriate questions about familiar foods, games, crafts, and activities. Younger children can point to pictures or raise their hands to answer.

What is the difference between This or That and Would You Rather?

This or That usually presents two short options, while Would You Rather often describes two longer situations. Both formats let players choose between alternatives and explain their preferences.

How can you make Thanksgiving This or That competitive?

Award points to players who correctly predict the majority answer, divide participants into teams, or keep a running score. A small prize can make the game more exciting, but it is not necessary.

Can teachers use Thanksgiving This or That in the classroom?

Yes. Teachers can use it as a speaking activity, a vocabulary exercise, a writing prompt, or a quick group-voting game. Choose questions appropriate for the students’ ages and classroom setting.

Is Thanksgiving This or That suitable for Friendsgiving?

Absolutely. Questions about favorite foods, music, games, hosting, and shared memories work well for Friendsgiving. Players can also create their own questions based on the group’s interests.


Conclusion

Thanksgiving This or That is an easy way to bring people together without complicated rules or supplies.

These 150 questions cover food debates, funny dilemmas, family traditions, classroom activities, and Friendsgiving favorites.

Choose a few questions, let everyone vote, and give people a chance to explain their choices. You can even create a bowl of question cards for guests to draw throughout the evening.

Whether you play before dinner or after dessert, the goal is to enjoy good conversation, share a few laughs, and make the holiday more memorable.


Read More Blogs

Leave a Comment