Stormcloaks vs Imperials: Which Is Better?

Choosing between the Stormcloaks and Imperials is one of the biggest decisions in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. Both factions want control of Skyrim, but they have different ideas about its future.

The Stormcloaks fight for independence and the right to worship Talos. The Imperials want to keep Skyrim within the Empire and believe unity is vital to surviving future conflicts. Yet neither side is perfect.

One raises questions about discrimination and nationalism, while the other must answer for its treatment of religious freedom and its agreement with the Thalmor.

So, should you join the Stormcloaks or Imperials? The answer depends on your character, your beliefs, and the kind of story you want to experience. Your choice affects the Civil War questline, important battles, and the rulers of several holds.

However, it does not lock you out of the main dragon storyline. This guide compares both factions, explains their strengths and weaknesses, explores their moral arguments, and covers rewards, canon, and role-playing choices. By the end, you will know which side best fits your playthrough.


Quick Answer: Stormcloaks or Imperials?

Choose the Stormcloaks if you support Skyrim’s independence, Nordic traditions, and freedom to worship Talos. Choose the Imperials if you value political unity, centralized rule, and the Empire’s ability to resist the Aldmeri Dominion.

Neither faction is a perfect choice. The Imperials offer stability and a united military, but their agreement to restrict Talos worship makes their position difficult to defend.

Your priorityBetter fit
Skyrim’s independenceStormcloaks
Freedom to worship TalosStormcloaks
Keeping Skyrim in the EmpireImperials
A united force against the ThalmorImperials
Playing a loyal Nord rebelStormcloaks
Playing a character who values orderImperials
Choosing based on gameplay rewards aloneEither faction

Our recommendation: Pick the Stormcloaks if independence matters most to your character. Pick the Imperials if you believe Skyrim needs the Empire to face a larger threat. If neither cause appeals to you, you can delay the decision while exploring the game.


Who Are the Stormcloaks?

The Stormcloaks are a rebel faction led by Ulfric Stormcloak, the Jarl of Windhelm. They want Skyrim to break away from the Empire and govern itself.

Their rebellion is closely tied to Nordic identity, traditional values, and the worship of Talos. Many Stormcloaks believe the Empire has surrendered too much power to the Aldmeri Dominion. They also resent the restrictions placed on their religious practices.

Why Do the Stormcloaks Want Independence?

The Empire signed the White-Gold Concordat after the Great War against the Aldmeri Dominion. This agreement included a ban on the worship of Talos, a figure revered as a god by many people in Skyrim.

The restriction angered many Nords. To the Stormcloaks, the Empire had betrayed its own people by accepting the ban. Ulfric presents independence as a way for Skyrim to regain control of its laws, traditions, and religious practices.

Their argument is simple: Skyrim should not have to follow rules imposed by a distant government that no longer protects its people as it once did.

See also  Summarize or Summarise: What is the correct word for use

However, independence would not automatically solve every problem. A separate Skyrim would still face questions about military strength, political leadership, trade, and relations with other provinces.

Stormcloaks: Pros and Cons

ProsCons
Fight for Skyrim’s independenceCould leave Skyrim more isolated
Oppose the ban on Talos worshipTheir nationalist outlook can exclude outsiders
Appeal to characters loyal to Nordic traditionsUlfric’s leadership is controversial
Offer a strong rebellion storylineCivil War fighting causes destruction
Support self-rule over Imperial controlA divided Skyrim may struggle against the Dominion

The Stormcloaks are a natural fit for players who want to defend local traditions and challenge Imperial authority. Yet players should also consider the faction’s treatment of people who do not fit its ideal of a true Nord.


Who Are the Imperials?

The Imperial Legion is the military force serving the Empire. In Skyrim, its campaign is led by General Tullius, who wants to defeat Ulfric’s rebellion and restore Imperial control.

The Empire has ruled large parts of Tamriel for generations. Its supporters argue that a united government provides stability, shared institutions, and a stronger defense against external enemies.

The Imperial position is not simply about loyalty to the emperor. It also reflects the belief that Skyrim cannot safely stand alone while the Aldmeri Dominion remains a powerful rival.

Why Do the Imperials Support the Empire?

The Empire’s leaders accepted the White-Gold Concordat to end the Great War. The agreement came with serious concessions, including restrictions on Talos worship.

Imperial supporters may dislike the ban, but they see the treaty as a way to gain time and preserve the Empire. They argue that fighting the Dominion again requires military strength and political unity.

General Tullius approaches the rebellion as a military problem. He wants to end the fighting and bring Skyrim back under Imperial rule. His position is practical, but it can seem harsh to people who believe the Empire has abandoned their rights.

The opening of Skyrim also complicates the Imperial case. Imperial soldiers are involved in the attempt to execute the player at Helgen, even though the player is not the intended target of the execution. This gives many players a personal reason to distrust the Legion.

Imperials: Pros and Cons

ProsCons
Keep Skyrim connected to the wider EmpireAccept restrictions on Talos worship
Offer a united military against the DominionTheir rule limits Skyrim’s independence
Appeal to characters who value orderThe Helgen execution harms their image
Support centralized governmentImperial policy can seem distant from local needs
Provide an alternative to Ulfric’s nationalismWinning the war does not guarantee religious freedom

The Imperials are a good fit for players who believe a united Tamriel has a better chance of resisting the Dominion. Still, choosing the Legion means accepting the difficult compromises the Empire has made.


Stormcloaks vs Imperials

The central difference is how each faction believes Skyrim should be governed. The Stormcloaks want independence, while the Imperials want to preserve the union.

FeatureStormcloaksImperials
LeaderUlfric StormcloakGeneral Tullius leads the campaign
Main goalIndependence for SkyrimKeep Skyrim in the Empire
Talos worshipOppose the banOperate under the Concordat
Political outlookNordic self-rule and traditionImperial unity and centralized rule
Military positionFight as a rebel armyFight as the Empire’s organized legion
Main strongholdWindhelmSolitude
Major criticismNationalism and discriminationReligious restrictions and Imperial control
Best role-playing fitIndependent, tradition-focused characterOrder-focused, Empire-loyal character

Neither faction represents a simple choice between good and evil. Both have understandable goals, but both also have serious weaknesses.


Stormcloaks or Imperials: Who Is Right?

There is no universally accepted answer. Each faction has a reasonable argument, and each has flaws that can make players question its cause.

The Stormcloaks’ Strongest Argument

Their strongest argument is that Skyrim should be free to govern itself. Many Nords consider the Talos ban an attack on their religion. They also believe the Empire has weakened itself by accepting the Dominion’s demands.

From this perspective, rebellion is an attempt to recover lost freedom. A character who values self-rule may see Ulfric’s cause as worth the cost of war.

The problem is that independence and religious freedom do not guarantee fair treatment for everyone. Windhelm’s social divisions, including the hardships faced by Dunmer residents in the Gray Quarter and the exclusion of Argonians from the city, complicate the Stormcloak message.

See also  Legal Counsel or Council: Which Word Is Correct?

The Imperials’ Strongest Argument

The Imperial argument is that Skyrim needs allies. The Empire may have lost ground and accepted an unpopular treaty, but it remains a major political and military power.

An independent Skyrim could struggle to resist the Aldmeri Dominion alone. From this perspective, the treaty was a painful compromise rather than a permanent surrender.

The problem is that the Empire asks people to accept limits on a deeply held religious belief. It also tries to suppress a rebellion whose supporters see the ban as an attack on their identity.

Which Argument Is Stronger?

Your answer depends on what you value most.

  • If freedom from outside rule matters most, the Stormcloaks have the stronger appeal.
  • If long-term military cooperation matters most, the Imperials make a stronger case.
  • If religious freedom is your main concern, the Stormcloak position is easier to support.
  • If political stability is your main concern, the Imperial position is easier to defend.

The game gives players room to disagree. That moral tension is a major reason the faction choice remains a popular debate.


Who Is More Evil: Stormcloaks or Imperials?

Neither faction is entirely good or entirely evil. Their actions, policies, and leaders give players reasons to criticize both sides.

The Stormcloaks fight for independence and religious freedom. Those goals can be admirable. However, some of their attitudes toward non-Nords reveal a narrow view of who belongs in Skyrim.

The Imperials represent a broader political union and offer a possible path to resisting the Dominion. However, their acceptance of the Talos ban shows how far they are willing to go to preserve that union. The attempt to execute the player at Helgen also makes the Legion difficult to trust at the start.

A useful way to judge both sides is to separate their goals from their methods.

QuestionStormcloaksImperials
Do they have a defensible goal?Yes, independence and religious freedomYes, unity and security
Do they make troubling compromises?Yes, particularly around exclusion and nationalismYes, particularly around the Concordat
Are they completely evil?NoNo
Can a player reasonably oppose them?YesYes

The more useful question is not which side is completely innocent. It is which faction’s weaknesses your character is willing to accept.


Stormcloaks or Imperials: Pros and Cons at a Glance

If you are still unsure, consider the practical and moral trade-offs together.

Choose the Stormcloaks if you:

  • Want Skyrim to become independent.
  • Strongly oppose the Talos ban.
  • Prefer a rebellion against a powerful government.
  • Are playing a Nord who values traditional Nordic identity.
  • Want to help Ulfric win control of Skyrim.

Choose the Imperials if you:

  • Want Skyrim to remain part of the Empire.
  • Believe unity is important against the Dominion.
  • Prefer a character who values law and political stability.
  • Want to support General Tullius and the Imperial Legion.
  • Disagree with Ulfric’s approach to leadership or nationalism.

Do not choose a faction only because its armor looks better or because you dislike one character. Think about what your Dragonborn would believe after seeing Helgen, learning about the Talos ban, and visiting Windhelm and Solitude.


Stormcloaks or Imperials: Which Side Has Better Rewards?

If you are choosing based on rewards, there is no major overall winner. Both factions offer their own Civil War questline, battles, and opportunities to earn equipment and loot.

The campaigns share many structural similarities. You join a faction, complete military objectives, fight for control of holds, and take part in the final campaign against the opposing side.

The main differences are the missions you complete, the characters you support, and the political outcome of the war.

Gameplay factorStormcloaksImperials
QuestlineStormcloak Civil War missionsImperial Civil War missions
Main baseWindhelmSolitude
Major battleAttack Whiterun during their campaignDefend Whiterun during their campaign
Faction equipmentStormcloak-themed gear and lootImperial-themed gear and loot
Main outcomeStormcloak victoryImperial victory
Overall reward advantageNo decisive general advantageNo decisive general advantage

Some equipment and quest rewards differ by mission, but neither faction gives a clear advantage in every category. Choose based on the campaign and story you want to experience rather than expecting one side to make your character much stronger.

See also  Kyoto or Osaka: Which City Should You Visit in Japan?

Stormcloaks or Imperials: Which Choice Is Canon?

Players often search for a definitive answer about which faction wins the Civil War in official Skyrim canon. The base game lets you complete either side’s campaign, but it does not provide a conclusive final winner that settles the question for every player.

Your chosen faction determines the outcome of the Civil War in your playthrough. If the Stormcloaks win, Ulfric’s side takes control. If the Imperials win, the Empire restores its authority in Skyrim.

That does not mean every player must choose one particular side to follow the official story. You can experience the game through either outcome.

For a lore-focused playthrough, consider the character’s background and beliefs. A Nord who resents the Talos ban may naturally support Ulfric. A character who fears the Dominion’s expansion may see the Empire as the more practical choice.

Bottom line: There is no need to select a faction simply because someone claims it is the only canon choice. The base game allows both outcomes.


Should a Khajiit Join the Stormcloaks or Imperials?

A Khajiit character makes the faction decision more interesting because race and social treatment can affect role-playing.

The Stormcloaks emphasize Nordic identity and Skyrim’s independence. Some of the attitudes shown by their supporters can make a Khajiit feel like an outsider. Windhelm’s restrictions on Khajiit caravans and the wider treatment of non-Nords make this concern especially relevant.

The Imperials may seem like the more natural choice for a Khajiit who prefers a multi-regional political system. However, that does not mean every Khajiit would support the Empire. The Empire’s policies, its relationship with the Dominion, and the character’s personal history all matter.

Consider these role-playing approaches:

  • A practical Khajiit: Join the Imperials because a united Empire may offer greater long-term security.
  • A freedom-loving Khajiit: Join the Stormcloaks because the character believes every province should govern itself.
  • A cautious Khajiit: Avoid committing early and learn more about both sides first.
  • A self-interested Khajiit: Choose whichever faction best fits the character’s goals, alliances, and survival.

There is no race-based rule that forces a Khajiit to join either faction. Your character’s experiences and beliefs can matter more than their race.


Are Stormcloaks or Imperials More Popular?

There is no reliable, universal measure that proves one faction is more popular among all Skyrim players. Community discussions show strong support for both sides, along with plenty of players who dislike both factions.

Some players favor the Stormcloaks because they oppose the Talos ban and want Skyrim to become independent. Others support the Imperials because they see the Empire as the best defense against the Dominion. Role-playing choices, favorite characters, and personal interpretations of the lore also influence opinions.

Reddit discussions reflect this range of views.

These discussions are useful for understanding player perspectives, but they are not scientific popularity polls. Reddit discussion on faction preferences and discussion of the lesser of two evils.

Instead of assuming that the most popular faction is the best one, decide which argument makes the most sense for your character.


Common Mistakes When Choosing a Faction

A few misunderstandings can make the decision seem more complicated than it is.

Assuming One Side Is Completely Good

Both factions have defensible goals and serious flaws. A more thoughtful choice considers both.

Choosing Only for Rewards

The Civil War questlines do not offer a decisive universal reward advantage. Story, role-playing, and faction loyalty may matter more.

Believing You Must Finish the War Immediately

You can delay committing to the Civil War while exploring much of Skyrim. Take time to learn about the factions before swearing an oath.

Assuming Your Race Determines Your Allegiance

A Nord may support the Empire, and a Khajiit may support the Stormcloaks. Role-playing does not have to follow a single racial stereotype.

Believing the Choice Replaces the Main Quest

The Civil War and the dragon storyline are related parts of Skyrim, but they are not the same questline. You can still pursue the main story whichever faction you choose.


1. Can You Join Both the Stormcloaks and Imperials?

You can interact with both factions before making your final commitment. However, you cannot complete both opposing Civil War campaigns normally in the same playthrough. Keep a separate save if you want to explore both outcomes.

2. Can You Switch Sides in Skyrim?

There is a limited opportunity to change allegiance during The Jagged Crown quest. You can deliver the crown to the opposing faction’s leader instead of your original contact. Once you move beyond that opportunity, switching sides is not normally available through the standard questline.

3. Does Joining the Stormcloaks or Imperials Affect the Main Story?

Your choice mainly affects the Civil War and control of Skyrim’s holds. It can also affect how the Civil War is handled during the main quest, including the negotiations associated with Season Unending. It does not remove the main dragon storyline.

4. Which Faction Should Beginners Choose?

Beginners can choose either faction without losing access to the core game. If you are unsure, continue exploring and learning about Skyrim before making a commitment. Your first playthrough is a good opportunity to choose based on your own interpretation of the story.

5. Is Ulfric Stormcloak a Villain?

Ulfric is a controversial leader rather than a simple villain. He fights for independence and Talos worship, but his political methods and attitudes toward outsiders raise concerns. Whether you see him as a hero, a flawed rebel, or an ambitious ruler depends on how you interpret his actions.

6. Why Does the Empire Ban Talos Worship?

The Empire accepted the White-Gold Concordat after the Great War with the Aldmeri Dominion. The treaty restricted Talos worship as part of the peace agreement. Many Nords view the ban as a betrayal, while Imperial supporters see the treaty as a painful compromise intended to preserve the Empire.

7. Can You Avoid Choosing Either Faction?

Yes. You can postpone the Civil War commitment and continue exploring Skyrim, completing side quests, and progressing through much of the main story. You do not need to settle the conflict as soon as you begin the game.


The choice between Stormcloaks or Imperials comes down to the future you want for Skyrim. The Stormcloaks fight for independence, Nordic traditions, and the right to worship Talos without Imperial restrictions.

The Imperials argue that Skyrim is safer within a united Empire that can prepare for another conflict with the Aldmeri Dominion.

Neither side is perfect. The Stormcloaks’ nationalist outlook raises concerns about discrimination, while the Imperials’ acceptance of the White-Gold Concordat shows the cost of their political compromises. Their Civil War campaigns also offer different battles, characters, and outcomes, but neither faction has a decisive overall advantage in rewards.

For players who value independence and religious freedom, the Stormcloaks may be the better choice. For those who value political unity and a broader military alliance, the Imperials may make more sense. Khajiit characters and other non-Nord characters can support either faction based on their own experiences and beliefs.

Ultimately, there is no universally correct answer. Choose the side that best fits your Dragonborn’s values, enjoy the questline, and remember that the decision is part of what makes Skyrim’s world feel personal.


Leave a Comment